Publication information |
Source: Salt Lake Tribune Source type: newspaper Document type: editorial Document title: “Missed a Great Chance” Author(s): anonymous City of publication: Salt Lake City, Utah Date of publication: 30 September 1901 Volume number: 42 Issue number: 172 Pagination: 4 |
Citation |
“Missed a Great Chance.” Salt Lake Tribune 30 Sept. 1901 v42n172: p. 4. |
Transcription |
full text |
Keywords |
Robert C. Titus; Loran L. Lewis; Leon Czolgosz (legal defense); Leon Czolgosz (trial: criticism); William H. Seward. |
Named persons |
William H. Seward; Robert C. Titus. |
Notes |
The editorial (below) is incorrect. Loran L. Lewis gave the closing argument for the defense, not Robert C. Titus. |
Document |
Missed a Great Chance
Some papers are praising the speech
made by Judge Titus in the Czolgosz trial. The Courier-Journal rightly, we think,
characterizes it as chiefly a defense by Judge Titus of Judge Titus for being
defendant’s counsel in the case. That occasion would have supplied a great lawyer
with a great opportunity. Suppose William H. Seward had received such an assignment
when he was in his prime and practicing law in the Empire State. Think what
a picture he would have drawn of his client; a man with brain and mind and heart
all perverted so far as to meditate such a murder and to be indifferent when
by the blow he struck he had killed the most blameless of men and whelmed a
nation in mourning. He would have shown by every act of the man that he was
in fact an irresponsible being, and his plea would have been that the law contemplated
the execution of no such a criminal, that it was the duty of the jury not to
consign him to death, but to solitary confinement, where he could never more
do harm, but in silence and solitude wait until in the course of nature he should
be called hence.
We do not think the plea would have availed anything,
for the public sentiment in that atmosphere would not have permitted it, but
it was the opportunity of a lifetime for Judge Titus, and he failed to improve
it.