Publication information |
Source: Blue Grass Blade Source type: newspaper Document type: editorial Document title: “Is M’Kinley Forgotten So Soon?” Author(s): anonymous City of publication: Lexington, Kentucky Date of publication: 14 September 1902 Volume number: 11 Issue number: 30 Pagination: [3] |
Citation |
“Is M’Kinley Forgotten So Soon?” Blue Grass Blade 14 Sept. 1902 v11n30: p. [3]. |
Transcription |
full text |
Keywords |
McKinley memorialization; William McKinley (criticism). |
Named persons |
Robert Burns; Euripides; Benjamin Franklin; Robert Fulton; Stephen Girard; Thomas Jefferson; Francis Marion; William McKinley; Robert Morris; Samuel F. B. Morse; Thomas Paine; John G. Whittier. |
Notes |
The editorial (below) appears in a section of the newspaper titled
“Timely Topics.”
The date of publication provided on the newspaper’s front page is September 14, E. M. 302. |
Document |
Is M’Kinley Forgotten So Soon?
Is a question now being asked by many editors
in their editorials—pointing to the fact that only $200,000, of the $1,500,000
necessary for the erection of his tomb, has been raised, and that with difficulty,
and no prospect of raising more.
In my opinion, a square block of granite costing
$500 is expenditure enough for marking the burial place of any man, however
great. These great shafts to great men are monstrosities. They are nothing but
a medieval attempt to follow the fashion of gorgeous burial of barbarous kings,
and popes.
The plain flat slab covering the remains of Benjamin
Franklin in the little graveyard in Philadelphia cost hardly $100. If the nation
feels that it is good enough for Benjamin Franklin, a common boulder is good
enough for McKinley.
His death, by violence, counts for nothing, since
he was the victim of his own political deals. Measured by the services done
his country, so long as the nation ignores, by testimonial, the services of
Thomas Paine, Robert Morris, Stephen Girard, Francis Marion, and other heroes
of the Revolution,—so long as a common brick vault is good enough to cover the
remains of Thomas Jefferson, why should the people of this country erect a gorgeous
mausoleum outrivalling those of oriental kings, over William McKinley.
It is all nonsense anyhow. A monument does not
make a man great in death.
“This monument does not make thee great, O Euripides,
but thou makest the monument great,” was engraved on the tomb of that great
philosopher.
Some of the finest and most expensive pieces of
monumental art in the cemeteries of Cincinnati stand over the carrion of bloated
beer brewers, while many of the children of science and of song lie in unmarked
graves.
There is some allowance to be made in erecting
a modest monument over a man like Burns, or Robert Fulton or Samuel F. B. Morse,
or John Greenleaf Whittier. They contributed much for all humanity. But Wm.
McKinley never contributed a word, thought or deed which was of universal benefit
to mankind, or which was superior to the average politician of the country,
or to the common soldier in the field.
To build a $1,500,000 monument to any man, and
to him particularly, while little children are dying in tenements for lack of
fresh air and proper food, is a sample of insanity continually breaking out
in the American character.
The failure to raise the money has its amusing
side. The trusts for which he was their pliable tool, won’t shell out. He made
them hundreds of millions, and now that he is dead, they won’t glorify him in
stone.
It is the old, old story. The moment you do an
unprincipled thing for some other man, that moment he ceases to respect you.
How can the trusts have any respect for McKinley?
There is absolutely no sense in piling up stone
over the grave. Statues of our great men in bronze or marble, are object lessons
to young America, and of these I approve, beside [sic] they cultivate the taste
for art. But many of these statues are of men of inferior parts, while those
who have shed luster upon the arts and literature and the sciences go unhonored.
It is time that public sentiment shift from this perpetuating the memory of
men whose only recommendation for honor is action in brutal war, and in their
place erect statues of some of the great women of America.