Publication information |
Source: Senate Documents Source type: government document Document type: interrogation transcript Document title: “Statement of Leon F. Czolgosz, Taken at Police Headquarters, 10.30 P. M., September 6, 1901, by Mr. Penney” Author(s): District Attorney’s Office, Erie County, Buffalo, NY Volume number: 12 Publisher: Government Printing Office Place of publication: Washington, DC Year of publication: 1919 Pagination: 64-74 |
Citation |
“Statement of Leon F. Czolgosz, Taken at Police Headquarters, 10.30 P. M., September 6, 1901, by Mr. Penney.” Senate Documents. Vol. 12. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1919: pp. 64-74. |
Transcription |
full text of interrogation transcript; excerpt of report |
Keywords |
Leon Czolgosz (interrogation transcript: full text); Leon Czolgosz (interrogation); Leon Czolgosz (confession); Leon Czolgosz; Leon Czolgosz (as anarchist); McKinley assassination (Czolgosz account); McKinley assassination (motive). |
Named persons |
William S. Bull; Patrick V. Cusack; Leon Czolgosz [also identified as Fred and Leo below]; Michael Donovan; Joseph Fowler; Francis E. Fronczak; John J. Geary; Frank T. Haggerty; Frederick Haller; Lewis W. Henafelt; John W. Holmlund; Samuel R. Ireland; Peter Kropotkin [misspelled below]; John Martin (a); William McKinley; John Nowak; Michalina Nowak; Matthew J. O’Loughlin; Thomas Penney; James L. Quackenbush; Clara M. Ragan [in notes]; Albert Solomon; Horace E. Story [in notes]; James A. Taggert. |
Notes |
Minor alterations have been made below to adjust for occasional formatting
inconsistencies in the original document. Boldfacing has been added in
order to facilitate the reading process.
As in the original source, the word president is given inconsistently
below with respect to capitalization.
The identity of Valleckt/Valletchy (below) cannot be determined.
Horace E. Story, a stenographer working for the Erie County District
Attorney’s office, is credited in the report (p. 64) with having originally
recorded the interrogation. Clara M. Ragan, a Department of Justice employee,
is credited (p. 64) with transcribing the interrogation record on 3 October
1919 for the purpose of inclusion in the report.
The document below is a portion of Exhibit VI (pp. 64-74), which comes
from a subsection titled “Activities of Emma Goldman.” It is part of a
larger section of the report titled “Exhibit No. 6: Emma Goldman” (pp.
35-137).
From title page: Letter from the Attorney General Transmitting in Response
to a Senate Resolution of October 17, 1919, a Report on the Activities
of the Bureau of Investigation of the Department of Justice Against Persons
Advising Anarchy, Sedition, and the Forcible Overthrow of the Government.
Document No. 153.
66th Congress, 1st Session, May 19-November 19, 1919. |
Document |
Statement of Leon F. Czolgosz, Taken at Police Headquarters, 10.30 P. M.,
September 6, 1901, by Mr. Penney
The following parties present all
or part of time statement was being taken: Mr. Cusack, Supt. Bull, Inspector
Donovan, Inspector Martin, Dr. Fowler, Mr. Quackenbush, O’Loughlin, H. Q.
Mr. P . Is
your face sore?
C . Where
they punched me.
Dr. F . Let
me see your tongue.
(Prisoner does so.)
Mr. P . Open
your eyes.
Dr. F . Your
head ache any?
C . Not
at all. [64][65]
Q. Are you subject to headache?
Have headache much? A. Sometimes.
Q. Not lately? A. No.
Mr. P . Been
feeling well lately? A. Kind of tired.
Q. How long have you been feeling
tired? A. Since they
Q. Since those fellows punched you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were not tired before, you
have not worked to-day? A. No, sir.
Q. Have you any trade, Fred? A.
Blacksmith’s helper; blacksmith shop.
Q. Did you ever work in Buffalo?
A. No, sir.
Q. Ever been here before? A.
Before.
Q. How long ago? A.
Probably about a year ago; somewheres around there.
Q. How long did you stay that time?
A. I stayed here for three or four nights, I think.
Q. Any relatives here? A.
No, sir.
Q. You have got some friends? A.
No, sir.
Q. What did you come here for that
time? A. Just to see the Falls.
Q. Where were you living at that
time? A. Cleveland.
Q. Is that your home, Cleveland?
A. Yes, sir; it is my home.
Q. Have you any relatives there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who are they? A.
My father and stepmother.
Q. Have you got any brothers and
sisters? A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many? A. Six
or seven brothers; and two sisters.
Q. Are they older than you? A.
Some is older, and some is younger.
Q. You live at home, when you are
in Cleveland? Do you? A. Yes; some of them live at home.
Q. Do you live with your father
and mother? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are you married? A.
No, sir.
Q. You have had a gun before, haven’t
you, Fred? A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did you do with that?
O’L . Tell
him; you said it was swiped on you.
C . It
was swiped on me.
Mr. P . When?
A. A couple or three weeks ago.
Q. What did you come to Buffalo
this time for? A. To strike something to do.
Q. Come here to get work? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. Did you go to school in Cleveland?
A. (Not heard.)
Q. You were born in Detroit? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. What nationality were your parents?
A. (Not heard.)
Q. Have you ever read any of the
works of Prince Kapartkin? A. Yes, sir; some of them.
Q. You know what he writes about,
do you know his theory of government; do you know what that means, Fred? Do
you understand me? Is there anything the matter with your head? A.
No, sir.
Q. Why don’t you hold it up, so
I can see; lean back in your chair, throw your head back, and open your eyes
if you are not too tired? You say you have read some of Prince Kapartkin’s writing?
Keep your head up so I can see your face? A. Not very much.
Q. You don’t believe in the republican
form of government; do you? A. No, sir.
Q. You don’t believe we should have
any rulers? A. No, sir.
Q. You believe it is right to kill
them, if necessary, don’t you? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was that your notion, when you
shot the man to-day? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was it for that reason? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. You went there with the intention
of killing him, didn’t you? A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long had you been planning
that? A. Oh, for a coupleabout two or three or four days
ago.
Q. Three or four days ago; days
or weeks? A. Days.
Q. What first put it into your head
to do that? Look up and tell me about that, will you? Was it after you came
to Buffalo you made up your mind to do that? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you talk it over with anyone,
or was it something you had read that suggested it to you, or something else?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Something you had read? Was it?
Look up, Fred, give your answer. Was it some book you read that suggested the
idea to you? A. Yes. sir.
Q. What had you been reading that
suggested that to you? A. That paper.
Q. What particular thing was it
that suggested your killing the President? Did you believe it would be a good
thing to get rid of him; good thing for the country? A. Yes, sir.
[65][66]
Q. Did you tell the people down
there where you have been rooming that you intended to use that gun that you
had bought? A. No, sir.
Q. How was it you had the gun when
you went in there this afternoon? A. In my right hand.
Q. Your handkerchief over it? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. Just take your handkerchief and
show me how you had it there?
(Witness indicates covering left hand with handkerchief.)
Q. Describe it? Hold it up about
the way you had it on your hand there?
(Witness does as directed.)
Q. It was not hanging down over
the sides that way? A. Yes, sir; I had it fixed up this way.
Q. Was the gun inside the handkerchief
or did you have the gun in your hand and the handkerchief over your hand? A.
The handkerchief was over the gun.
Q. Did you hold the gun outside
the handkerchief? A. No, sir.
Q. You had hold of the gun, and the handkerchief
over your hand and the gun? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have it that way when you started
in the line to go up toward the President? A. No, sir.
Q. Where did you fix it? A.
In the row.
Q. While you were going up with the crowd?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What pocket did you carry the gun in
when you took it out in your hand? In your coat pocket or hip pocket? A.
Hip pocket.
Q. As you were going up in the crowd, you
took it out and fixed your handkerchief over it? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you say anything to the President
before you shot him? A. No, sir.
Q. Did he shake hands with you? A.
No, sir.
Q. He put out his hand to shake hands?
A. I don’t think he did.
Q. You were close to him? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. When you shot you fully intended to
kill him; that was your intention when you started out; you thought it would
be a good thing to get rid of him as President, didn’t you? What do you say,
Fred?
Inspector M .
Leo.
Mr. P . What
do you say, Leo? That is right? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You fully intended to kill him when
you shot? Answer the question. Yes, you say? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you have been intending to kill
him for the last three days? That has been your plan? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You followed him down to the Falls to-day
for that purpose? A. No, sir.
Q. You were down to the Falls? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. You had your gun with you? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. And if you had the right opportunity,
you would have shot him then? A. No, I don’t think I would.
Q. Had you planned to shoot him this afternoon
in the Temple of Music? A. Yes.
Q. That has been your plan, from the beginning?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you read the program in the newspapers?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You knew he was going to be there, and
have a public reception? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you belong to any societies? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. What kind of societies do you belong
to? A. Knights of the Golden Eagle.
Q. Any other society? A. No,
sir.
Q. What do the Knights of the Golden Eagle
believe in, so far as government is concerned? A. Nothing to do
with government.
Q. Fraternal organization? A.
Lodges.
Q. Social? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you belong to any club, number of
men, you gather together, and talk over these principles of government? A.
No, sir.
Q. Haven’t you ever met with men and talked
that over? A. Yes, sir; but I didn’t belong to any society.
Q. Have you ever taken any obligation or
sworn any oath to kill anybody; you have, haven’t you; look up and speak; haven’t
you done that? A. No, sir.
Q. But you have, haven’t you, taken some
obligation upon yourself, or taken some oath, that you would kill the President,
have you? A. No, sir.
Q. What did she say? A. She
didn’t like them. [66][67]
Q. Anything else did she say? A.
She said a good deal more, but I can’t remember all.
Q. You got the idea that she thought it
would be a good idea if we didn’t have this form of government? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. You wanted to help on in her work, and
thought this was the best way to do it; was that your idea; of [sic] if you
have any other idea, tell us what it was? —A. She didn’t tell me to do
it.
Q. You thought it would be a nice thing;
she would like to have you do it? —A. I didn’t ask her whether she would
or not.
Q. You think she would approve of it? A.
Maybe she would.
Q. You believed it was the proper thing
to do; didn’t you? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Does your parents and your brothers
and sisters believe the same way you do about these things? A.
I don’t think so.
Q. Did you ever talk with them about it?
A. No, sir.
Q. How much did you pay for your gun? A.
$4.50; I paid something like that.
Q. When you bought that, you intended to
use it on the President; didn’t you; what do you say, Leo? A. Yes,
sir.
Q. That is what you came to Buffalo for?
A. To see if I could find something to do.
Q. Was not one of your objects to shoot
the President? A. No, sir.
Q. Not until you came out here? A.
Until three or four days ago.
Q. What was it that suggested it to you
three or four days ago? Can you remember? A. No, sir.
Q. Can’t you give us some idea what first
put it into your mind? Can you? What was the first thing that put this into
your mind, you must have had some beginning about it; something must have started
it in your mind? A. I didn’t believe in any government.
Q. You don’t believe in any rulers; you
have not believed in that for a long time? A. No, sir.
Q. What was this that first put this into
your mind; have you been reading something since you came to Buffalo that suggested
it to you, had you? Speak up, Leo? A. I read some of the papers.
Q. What did you read? A. I
read something in the papers; I can’t just remember what it was.
Mr. O’L .
What was the name of the papers you were reading? A. Free Society
papers.
(Superintendent Bull and Mr. Haller came in; also
Detective Geary.)
Mr. PENNEY.
Leo, will you draw up here a little closer, and I will read this statement to
you slowly?
(Mr. Penney reads statement taken by Mr. Haller.)
Q. You said you thought of shooting President
McKinley three days ago; you said you first thought of it three or four days
agoyou planned to kill McKinley; is that right? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you intended to do that all the
time when you bought the revolver, and you intended to kill him when you fired
it off; that is true, isn’t it? A. Yes, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I walked around town” A.
I didn’t go home after 6.
Q. “I was living with myself?” A.
Yes; my folks live there.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. You didn’t work here at all? A.
No, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. Stayed around. A. He repeated
that twice.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “Reaching home about 11 o’clock.” A.
About half past 10 or 11 o’clock.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I want a clean shirt.” A.
Yes; they told me I should
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “It is a good many weeks since I saw
him.” A. It is.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. My name is Leon F. How do you pronounce
last name? A. Czolgos [sic].
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “Never was in Buffalo before this year.”
A. That is wrong.
Mr. H . That
is changed.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. I had a letter to him. Had you ever
met Nowak? A. No, sir. [67][68]
Q. What did you mean by that? A.
I had a letter from the lodgeto which I belongKnights of the Golden
Eagle, written to the Noble Chief; I think it was from the Noble Chief, notifying
Noble Chief
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I said to the officer I done my duty
in shooting the President.” Did you say that to the officer? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. Which one? A. The one that
brought me down.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I saw it in the papers in Chicago that
the President was to be here.” That is right? A. Yes, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I made my plans for shooting the President
this morning.” A. That is a mistake; that should be three or four
days ago.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I don’t believe in voting.” Is that
your idea? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You don’t believe in the present form
of government; is that the idea? —A. Yes, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
(Mr. Haggerty makes correction in written statement
of prisoner; about place, “it is my principle; I don’t believe in voting.”)
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I am an anarchist.” Is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. P to
Haggerty. Put in the words, “Am an anarchist.”
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “About 10 miles from Cleveland on trolley
line.” You are watching this, are you? If there is not anything right about
this, call my attention to this. A. I don’t know where she lives.
Q. I mean any of the substance of this
that is not right. A. That is not right; she lives 10 milesvillage
of Bedford.
Q. “I heard her talk in Bedford, Cleveland.”
A. Whether she lives on the trolley line or in the village of Bedford,
I don’t know.
Q. It is in that direction? A.
Yes, sir.
Mr. P . You
better make that she lives out in the direction of Bedford, south of Cleveland;
that is what you mean to say? A. Yes, sir.
(Haggerty makes corrections as noted above.)
Q. “I believe in free love.” That is true?
A. Yes, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I know a saloon keeper that belongs
to the club.” A. They asked if I knew the saloon keepers in Cleveland;
I told them I knew that fellow; he belonged to that club.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “This man did not belong to the club;
my former statement that he did was not correct.” That is true? That corrects
that? A. Yes, sir.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I didn’t like their style.” A.
That quarrel wants to be crossed off.
Q. “I had a quarrel with my father and
stepmother”; do you want that, I didn’t just quarrel with them? A.
I want
Q. What you want to leave in there is
A. I didn’t like their style, and left.
Q. That is the way you want that sentence
to begin? A. Yes.
Q. I will strike out, “I had a quarrel
with my father and stepmother; I didn’t just quarrel with them.” I will strike
it out down to there; now it reads, “I didn’t like their style”? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. “And I left and went to Cleveland,”
etc.
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “After I left farm, I was in the anarchist
hall.”
(Correction made by Haggerty.)
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I had the money to go there; I saved
it when I was in the mill; $300 or $400.” Is that right? A. Yes,
sir.
Q. Read down here with me.
(Prisoner does as directed.)
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “I gave some to my father.” A.
It says there I gave him $300 or $400.
Q. No; it says you saved $300 or $400;
I will read it to you again.
(Does so.)
(Mr. Penney continues reading.)
Q. “The gun was in my room yesterday.”
Is that right? A. Yes, sir. [68][69]
Q. “I went right in when he came.” A.
When I went, he was in already.
Q. When you got to the building, the president
was already there? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you mean to say that the president
got there before you did? A. The president got in there before
I did.
Q. Didn’t you tell me a little while ago
that you waited for him; that you got there about an hour before the president
came? A. On the ground [sic], but I was not in the building.
Q. Did you get into the building before
the president? A. After.
Q. What you mean was that you got into
the grounds before the President came? A. It says that I was by
the building.
Q. What you mean to say is that you got
in on the grounds before the President came? A. Yes, sir.
Q. But you didn’t go into the building
where the President was until after he was in there? A. Yes, sir.
Q. “I went right in when he came.” A.
He was in there when I came.
Q. Did you see him go in? A.
They told me he was in.
Q. Did you see the President go in? A.
No, sir.
Q. “I wrapped gun in my handkerchief at
boarding house.” I thought you said you wrapped it in the building? A.
I could not carry it that way right along. I wrapped it up, and when I got to
the building I pulled my handkerchief out.
Q. When you got into the building the gun
was in your pocket? A. It was in my hand.
Q. Not when you went in? A.
Not when I went in; but when I went in a little ways.
Q. But when you went in it was in your
pocket? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was the handkerchief around it? A.
Yes, sir; it was around; I believe I had two handkerchiefs if I am not mistaken.
Q. How did you fix it up; you fixed it
up after you got into the building? —A. I had it fixed up; I stuck the
hand under the revolver.
Q. “I didn’t think one shot was enough.”
A. When I shot twice, I was knocked down; that is what I wanted
to say.
Q. “Tramped on and the gun taken away from
you”? A. Yes, sir; that is right; I got hit with a billy; some
of the officers hit me twice over the head.
Q. If you had not been knocked down, would
you have fired off more? A. I don’t know.
Q. That was your intention? A.
I don’t know if I would fire any more shots or not.
Q. You planned three or four days ago to
shoot the President? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And when you shot him you intended to
kill him? That is what you told me a little while ago; that is right? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. And the reason for your intention to
kill him was that you didn’t believe in having rulers over us, or having presidents?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Didn’t believe in our form of Government?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You fully understood what you were about?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You understood that you were taking
the life of a person; that you were willing to do that; you understood that?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. But you were willing to sacrifice his
life to benefit the country? A. Yes, sir.
(Detective Solomon present.)
Q. You were willing to sacrifice yourself
to benefit the country? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You realize that you are putting yourself
in a serious position to do that, you fully understood that it was quite an
undertaking? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Few men would have the courage to do
anything of that kind? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You knew that, you felt that you had
more courage than the average man to do a thing of that kind; that you were
willing to take all of the responsibility? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Even though it might put your own life
at stake? You were willing to take that chance, weren’t you? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. You had in these halls or clubs or meetings,
you heard people talk about the duty of people who believe as you do, toin
these meetings you used to attend in Cleveland, you heard about the people,
men and women, talk about the duty they were under to do great deeds for the
benefit of the people? A. And [sic] do you mean? [69][70]
Q. For instance, like yourself, it was
your duty? A. I never heard them say that.
Q. Didn’t you ever swear an oath? A.
No, sir.
Q. That you would take the life of any
ruler, such as president. A. No, sir.
Q. You have heard them talk about their
duty to educate the people to this form of government? A. Yes,
sir.
Q. And to do everything in their power
to change the form of government; you have heard them say that, haven’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You wanted to have it clear in here
that what you meant to say in the former part of this statement was that you
were on the grounds about an hour before the President arrived this afternoon?
A. Yes, sir; I was on the grounds.
Q. And that you didn’t enter the Temple
of Music, the building where the shooting occurred, until after the President
went in; that is what you meant to say? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Everything that I have read to you in
these papers is absolutely true, isn’t it? A. Yes; but there is
somewheres in the start, where you commenced to read, you said you would change
it after a while
Q. It was corrected later on; for instance,
in the beginning of it, a statement is made, but as you did here, you say, I
didn’t mean to say that, but I meant to say this; so that the whole thing is
explained; you understand that? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You can read, yourself? A.
I can’t read to-night.
Q. If that is right, just write your name
there; right under there; put your handkerchief down, and write on that line
in there; sign your name in there; sign your right name.
(Prisoner does as requested.)
Q. I will tell you what I would like to
have you do. You can write pretty well; just take the pen there; the other hand;
start up there on the line and say, write what you intended to do, and what
you did do, in the Temple this afternoon; start in: I arrived at the.
A. Didn’t I tell you I was
Q. Write it yourself; so you will have
it in the way you wanted to put it yourself. A. I signed that paper
there; it is in there.
Q. I understand it is in there; if you
want to put it in your own way? A. Didn’t you have it there? I
will put it in my own way; I said it, and I signed it. Isn’t it just as good?
Mr. Q .
I thought he might want to have a statement published to the world showing what
his views were.
Mr. P . Did
you hear what that gentleman said? He said that perhaps you would want to write
something that you would want the people to hear. You have done this great deed
for their benefit; you want to say something to them that you have done this
great deed, this courageous deed for their benefit; write something there that
can be published in the newspapers? This won’t be published. They won’t publish
anything unless you write it yourself. Write anything that you want to. A.
I don’t want
Q. You only need write a few words, simply
telling the people that you intended to kill President McKinley and shot him
because you believed you were doing your duty to the people. Is that your idea?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Take your pen and write that. A.
The reporter will write that.
Q. They won’t publish it unless it is your
writing. A. I will sign it; he can put it on, and I will sign it.
I don’t see why, if he writes it; I will sign it.
Q. It will only be two or three lines.
O’L . Go
ahead. A. Can’t the reporter write it over there?
Mr. P . No;
we can not take his writing. Write whatever you please up there about what you
did; get at it. A. I could not. Could not the reporter write it,
and I will sign it, just as good?
Mr. Q .
He might make a statement to the reporter in his own words.
Mr. P . All
right; make it. Make your own statement to this man, so he will write it out.
(Haggerty writes at prisoner’s dictation.)
“I killed President McKinley because”
(Prisoner hesitates, and then)
“Put on there that I killed President McKinley
because I done my duty.”
Mr. Q .
Do you want to say anything else to the people? A. I don’t believe
one man should have so much service and another man should have none. [70][71]
(Detective Holmlund present, also Donovan.)
Mr. P . Do
you know a man by the name of Valleckt here, a shoemaker? A. No,
sir.
Q. Do you know a shoemaker in Buffalo?
A. No, sir.
Q. You have got some friends that you have
been with since you have been here; been on the street talking with? A.
I have no friends.
Q. Acquaintances you have been walking
around with? A. No, sir.
Q. You don’t know a shoemaker by the name
of Valletchy? A. No, sir.
(Detective Solomon present.)
(Prisoner puts date on last statement; writes
his name.)
Mr. P . Put
the year down; what is the year?
(Prisoner writes same in.)
Q. Now write your name. I suppose you planned
this all out for two or three days; been thinking it over? A. Yes,
sir.
Q. You knew there would be a big crowd
there when the President would be around? A. I didn’t know.
Q. You thought there would be? Had an idea
there would be a big crowd at the reception? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was it your idea that you could in the
confusion get away, after you had shot him? A. No, sir.
Q. What did you intend to do, after you
had shot him; what was your intention then? What did you expect to happen after
you shot him? A. I expected after I shot him that I would be catched
at it.
Q. You expected to be arrested? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. Didn’t you expect to get away in the
crowd? A. No, sir.
Q. You didn’t intend to do that? A.
No, sir.
Q. Didn’t you intend to try to get away?
A. No, sir.
Q. You were willing to sacrifice yourself
to get rid of the President; was that the idea? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Fully realizing the consequences; did
you? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You realized that you might be electrocuted
or hung for it? A. Yes. sir.
Q. You were willing to take that chance?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Q .
You are not sorry now, are you?
Mr. P .
You are not sorry that you killed him now, are you, you are still willing to
suffer for what you have done, aren’t you? It is a great thing that you have
done, people all over the country will be talking about it; you are willing
to take that for the glory it will give you; speak up; aren’t you? A.
What?
Q. You are willing to take the chance and
consequences of what you have done; you are not sorry you did it, are you? You
would do it over again, would you not? A. I don’t know whether
I would or not.
Q. You are not sorry you did it, are you;
just think what all your people will say of you up there in Cleveland in those
meetings; the great savior of the country, don’t you know that?
(Haggerty reads it.) “I was willing to take the
chance of being hung if I killed the President; I was willing to take the consequences.”
Mr. P . You
realized what it meant, and you are willing to take the consequences, if you
could accomplish your purpose? A. Read it over.
(Haggerty reads.) “I planned this all out for
two or three days; I had an idea there would be a big crowd at the reception;
I expected I would be arrested; I did not intend to get away. I was willing
to take the chance of being electrocuted or hung if I could kill the President;
I am willing to take the consequences; I realize what it meant.” Is that right?
Mr. P . That
is correct? A. Read it again.
Q. “I planned it all out for two or three
days.” That is right? A. Yes, sir.
Q. “I had an idea there would be a big
crowd at the reception.” A. Yes, sir; that is right.
Q. “I was willing to take the chance”?
A. No; only before that; I don’t want any further than that.
Q. “I was willing to take the chance of
being electrocuted or hung.” You said you were? A. No, sir; I want
that changed. Just up to that.
Q. Up to where? If I could kill the President;
you knew that when you shot him A. I just want to have
Q. You knew that when you shot him that
you would be arrested. You say that? A. Yes, sir. [71][72]
Q. And you knew if you killed a man that
you would be hung or electrocuted? You knew that was the penalty, didn’t you;
didn’t you know that? You knew that the laws of this country provide if he kills
another he is to suffer death. Didn’t you know that? That is right, isn’t it?
A. I would not want to have it in this
Q. Well, I want to know whether that is
true or not? A. Up to here it is true.
Q. I want to know whether this part is
true, “I was willing to take the chance of being electrocuted or hung.” Were
you willing to take that chance? You must have realized that was the consequence,
if that was so then you did take the chance, didn’t you? You understand that
without meditating on it so long. A. I don’t want it that way.
Q. It is not a question whether it is what
you want; it is a question whether it was right. A. I knew
Q. You knew if you killed a man you would
be hung or electrocuted, didn’t you? You know that is the law of this country,
don’t you? Speak, you know whether that is so or not? A. I know
the law does that
Q. You knew if you killed a man you would
have to suffer the penalty of the law, isn’t that so? A. Yes; have
to suffer the penalty of the law.
Q. When you shot the man you knew you were
taking that chance, didn’t you; isn’t that right, come now, speak up, isn’t
that correct? All I want to know is whether that is a true statement? A.
Some of it is true.
Q. Isn’t it all true; didn’t you when you
shot this man take the chance of being electrocuted and hung, and didn’t you
know when you shot him that you were taking that chance?
Mr. O’L .
Somebody told you that you would not?
(Mr. Penney leaves room; Detective Henafelt present;
Detective Ireland, Secret Service, enters.)
Q. What do you say about that now? A.
Isn’t that correct?
Mr. P . Let
me read this to you again. You say that “I planned this for two or three days.”
That is correct? A. Yes, sir.
Q. “I had an idea that there would be a
big crowd at the reception.” That is correct, is it? A. Yes, sir.
Q. “I expected I would be arrested.” That
is correct? A. Yes, sir.
Q. “I did not intend to get away.” That
is correct? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You have already said it is, is it right?
“I was willing to take the chance of being electrocuted or hung.” Is that right;
you knew that you took that chance, didn’t you? Say yes or no; you knew when
you shot the President you were taking that chance? Speak up. A.
What is that?
Q. “I was willing to take the chance of
being electrocuted or hung if I could kill the President.” Is that right? Is
it correct? You intended to kill the President? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You fully intended to when you shot
him? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And for all you know he is dead; you
intended to kill him? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You are willing to take the consequences
of your act, aren’t you? How will that suit you, “I am willing to take the consequences
of what I did”? Will that suit you? Do you want this last part, “I am willing
to take the consequences”? A. I want it struck out up to there.
How far do you read?
Q. From there down? A. I want
this from here to here. (Prisoner indicates.)
Q. You want him to state on there that
it is true, but you rather not have it in the statement? A. No,
sir. I want to have that out.
Q. That is true, isn’t it? What do you
say?
Mr. O’L .
Yes or no? A. No, sir.
Mr. P . You
don’t mean to say that you didn’t intend to kill the President? A.
Yes, I did.
Q. Well, put it your own way; I would like
to have the last four lines stricken out. A. No; I don’t want to
have that that way, at all
Q. I was going to say that you wanted the
last four lines stricken out? —A. No
Q. You just want to have it stricken out?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. All right; strike it out.
(Haggerty does it.)
Mr. P . Sign
it. A. Read it.
Q. “I planned this all out for two or three
days; I had an idea that there would be a big crowd at the reception; I expected
I would be arrested. I did [72][73] not intend
to get away.” Sign on that line. A. I would like to have fair trial
put on there, too.
Q. You will get a fair trial, all right;
write it there yourself, I would like to have a fair trial, and sign it.
(Prisoner writes, and partially strikes out portion.)
Mr. Q .
Where did you get the name Fred Nieman? Did your boss give it to you?
Detective H .
Nieman is your English name; didn’t you bring a recommendation from Mrs. Nowak’s
friends in Cleveland? Didn’t they give you a writing to Mrs. Nowak? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. They took you in and gave you a room?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Nieman is your English name? A.
No; just picked that up.
Detective O’L .
Who gave you the card? A. I don’t remember his name.
Detective H .
Some people in Cleveland? A. No; here in Buffalo.
Detective O’L .
Who gave you that card? A. What?
Mr. H . Recommendation;
when you went out there; you told them some man in Cleveland, you mentioned
his name, had been here at the Polish singing celebration; had recommended you
to go there, to that place? You met a man in Toledo told you about Nowak’s place?
A. No, sir.
Q. What was that bundle you took away with
you this morning from the house? A. Lots of letters and papers;
no letters; common papers.
Q. What did you do with them? A.
Throw them in the water-closet.
Q. Over where? A. In a saloon
there somewhere.
Q. Where? Near Nowak’s place? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. Which saloon was that? A.
Why the street runs across from Broadway, and it runs north.
Q. Saloon on Boadway? [sic] A.
No
Q. First street that crosses Broadway,
after you leave Nowak’s? A. Yes, sir.
Q. How far was the saloon from Broadway?
A. Just a few doors.
Q. On which side of the street that runs
north from Broadwayon the other side or this sideeast side or west
side? A. I think the east side.
Q. The side nearest Nowak’s; on the downtown
side? A. Yes, sir; downtown.
Q. Left-hand side as you go up from Broadway?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was up from Broadway? A.
Toward the marketit is the left-hand side; I threw some of them there,
and the rest outside.
Q. Did you open the bundle? A.
Yes, sir.
Q. What did you do that for? A.
Just common papers that I had saved up for a week or two.
Q. Why did you save them? A.
I saved them since Monday.
Q. What did you save them for? A.
They laid there, and I thought I would carry them away some time.
Q. You threw some in this water-closet
in the saloon? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where did you throw the others?
Detective H .
This was not a water-closet; it was a s house; it was out in the yard;
behind the saloon? A. They have no s houses; they have sewer
pipes out there.
Mr. P .
What part of Poland does your people come from; are they Russian or Austrian?
A. They come from the German Provinces; they are Polish.
Q. But there are Russian Poles and Austrian
Poles; what part of the old country did they come from? A. From
Russia.
Q. Russia Poland? A. Yes,
sir.
(Dr. Fronczak comes in and speaks to prisoner
in foreign language.)
Dr. F .
He comes from Germany.
Mr. P . You
told me Russia. A. Yes; they come from Germany.
Dr. F
(again talks to prisoner). They come from Inowroclaw, Province of Posen, about
3 miles from the eastern frontier of Russia.
C (in
English). I don’t come from there, though.
(Clerk Taggert, Detective Solomon, Quackenbush,
Detective O’Loughlin, Inspector Donovan, Dr. Fronczak, Superintendent Bull,
Detective Geary present.)
Dr. F
(after talking with prisoner). I was born in Detroit; educated in Alpena, Mich.;
father alive; mother dead; father lives at Warrenville.
C (interrupting
in English). Not Warrenville; Warrensville. [73][74]
Dr. F
(continuing). Ten miles from Cleveland; he says the reason why he killed the
President is
(Prisoner interrupts him; talking some other language
than English.)
Dr. F
(continuing). The reason why he was killed is he doesn’t believe one tyrant
should rule all and everybody should bow to him or the poor man should look
and applaud, and then consider it a great privilege even to do that, and he
took three days ago the first notion of killing him, and I asked him didn’t
he see the parade yesterday; how he could take the idea three days ago; about
bowing to him; he said his Government was pretty bad, and he didn’t think it
was proper that a tyrant of that kind should rule the people. (Talks further
with prisoner.) He says I was reading various papers; and he names four socialistic
papers, the Przedsiit, of New York; the Robotnik (prisoner interrupts Dr. Fronczak)
and American, Toledo.
C . And
the Free Society.
Dr. F
(continuing). He says he never went to church; used to go to church once in
a while, but there was some platonic nonsense, and he quit going to church.
He went to public and Polish schools in Alpena.